Two listsPengy on MM2Values.com vs Supreme Values
from supremevalues.com, the other community list. Why they differThere is a 67% split here. Items this far apart are the ones people get burned on. Their figure is down 1 (-25.0%) since the last time they ran it.
What our traders do with Pengy
Too few trades for Pengy in the last 30 days to show counts. It is rarely posted here.
Value changes on MM2Values.com
No change since Sep 26, 2026: 1 at every snapshot we have kept.
We save the MM2Values.com list each time it changes, starting Sep 26, 2026.
How much is Pengy worth in MM2?
Traders put Pengy at 1. Of the 83 pets items we price, it comes 41st. Of all 1,033 priced items, it comes 545th. Zombie Dog is the priciest pets at 725. That is 725x Pengy. Against a median of 1 for the tier, it lands about the same as the middle.
The source rates its demand at 1/10. That is the floor for the pets tier. 29 items rate higher. Expect a slow sale. A small add often helps it move.
Any of these gets you close: 5x Scarecrow (0.2 each), or 6x Candleflame (0.16 each), or 8x Teddy (0.12 each). Just below it is UFO at 1, and just above is Seahorsey at 1. Either one can stand in without changing the total much.
What can you trade for Pengy?
Stacks that come out close to even against Pengy's 1.
| Offer | Each | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 5× Scarecrow | 0.2 | 1 |
| 6× Candleflame | 0.16 | 0.96 |
| 8× Teddy | 0.12 | 0.96 |
Each row is rounded to the nearest whole item. For the precise numbers, use the trade calculator.
About pets items in MM2
Cute, and harder to move than the value suggests.
This is the one category where what people want and what the number says drift furthest apart.
Expect to wait. There are far fewer people looking for pets than for knives, so your offer sits longer.
Trading in Discord? Use /value and /wfl right in the chat.
Add to DiscordItems similar to Pengy
Closest pets items by value. Useful for stacking or substituting in a trade.
Pengy: quick answers
How much is Pengy worth in MM2?
In October 2026, Pengy is worth 1. It holds place 41 of 83 in the pets tier.
What can I trade for Pengy?
Fair offers include 5x Scarecrow, 6x Candleflame, 8x Teddy. You can also split it: 1x Scarecrow plus 5x Candleflame comes to 1.
Is Pengy rare in MM2?
Rarity is rated 3. 15 pets items score higher and 35 score lower. It is genuinely hard to come by.
Is Pengy worth more than Seahorsey?
No. Both Pengy and Seahorsey have a listed value of 1. Neither side has a listed-value advantage, and both are rated 1 for demand.
Values: MM2Values.com (list updated October 28, 2026) and Supreme Values. Trade counts: ours. How we source.
Background on how Pengy was obtained and released: Pengy on the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki