Two listsFairy on MM2 Values vs Supreme Values
from supremevalues.com, the other community list. Why they differThe second list is 67% higher. Do not trade this on one number alone. They moved it down 1 (-25.0%) at their last refresh.
How much is Fairy worth in MM2?
Fairy is worth 1 today. Out of the 83 pets items that carry a price, that puts it at number 35. Across every priced item in the game it is number 596. The most anyone pays in this tier is 725, for Zombie Dog. That is hundreds of times Fairy. Tier median is 1, and this one comes in about the same as that figure.
Fairy has a source demand rating of 1/10 and a rarity rating of 3. These are community ratings, not measured sale times or guaranteed offers. Compare the actual items on both sides before accepting. Fairy is marked "Stable" by the source list. This describes its current rating; it does not predict a future price.
A fair offer for Fairy lands near 5x Scarecrow (0.2 each), or 6x Overseer (knife) (0.16 each), or 8x Teddy (0.12 each). Reindeer at 1 and Overseer Eye at 1 sit either side of it. Both are fair stand-ins.
Fair offers for Fairy
Stacks that come out close to even against Fairy's 1.
| Offer | Each | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 5× Scarecrow | 0.2 | 1 |
| 6× Overseer (knife) | 0.16 | 0.96 |
| 8× Teddy | 0.12 | 0.96 |
Multiples are rounded to whole items, so totals can land a few percent either side. Check the exact split in the trade calculator.
A quick word on pets items
Buy them because you like them.
Pets are the closest thing MM2 has to a collectible you buy for fun rather than profit.
Expect to wait. There are far fewer people looking for pets than for knives, so your offer sits longer.
Items similar to Fairy
Closest pets items by value. Useful for stacking or substituting in a trade.
Fairy: quick answers
How much is Fairy worth in MM2?
Right now Fairy is worth 1. That was true on October 2026 and it holds 35th place out of 83 pets items.
What can I trade for Fairy?
Fair offers include 5x Scarecrow, 6x Overseer (knife), 8x Teddy. Build any combination that lands near 1. Test the combination in the calculator first.
Is Fairy rare in MM2?
Rarity is rated 3 and demand 1, which puts it in the TIER 3 bracket of pets items. Not rare at all. There are plenty about.
Is Fairy worth more than Overseer Eye?
No. Both Fairy and Overseer Eye have a listed value of 1. Neither side has a listed-value advantage; demand and the actual offer still matter.
Source list rebuilt October 8, 2026. The rebuild date describes the source list, not a confirmed change to this item's value. We check for new data regularly; listed values are guidance, not guaranteed offers. The notes above are written and kept up by the MM2 Values Team, and how we source and check everything is in our editorial policy.
MM2 values are player-driven trade units. They are not Robux and carry no real-world money value.
Background on how Fairy was obtained and released: Fairy on the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki