Two listsShadow Pumpkin on MM2 Values vs Supreme Values
from supremevalues.com, the other community list. Why they differThe second list is 40% higher. Do not trade this on one number alone. They have cut it by 2 (-28.6%) since their previous update.
How much is Shadow Pumpkin worth in MM2?
3 is what Shadow Pumpkin is worth at the moment. In the pets tier that is 29th of 83. Site wide it is 494th of 1,072. The usual pets is worth 1. This sits 3x that. Top of the tier is Zombie Dog at 725, about 242x what you have here.
2 out of 10 is quiet. Shadow Pumpkin works better as part of a stack. Neither number is pulling ahead. Rarity 3, demand 2, and a price that behaves. The value has settled. Neither side of a trade should argue about it much.
Roughly even offers: 3x Xeno Knife (1 each), or 5x Eyes (0.6 each), or 5x Pumpkin (0.6 each). Look either side and you get Nobledragon at 3 and Chroma Fire Dog at 3. Close enough to trade in place of this one.
Building a trade for Shadow Pumpkin
Stacks that come out close to even against Shadow Pumpkin's 3.
| Offer | Each | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 3× Xeno Knife | 1 | 3 |
| 5× Eyes | 0.6 | 3 |
| 5× Pumpkin | 0.6 | 3 |
Expect a few percent either way once rounding is applied. The trade calculator shows the exact difference.
Where pets items fit in MM2
Cosmetic, seasonal, and thinly traded.
Most pets came from events that ran once. A few came from boxes that are still around. The first group holds value and the second does not.
Pet demand is thin, so a pet at 60 is harder to move than a godly at 60 even though the calculator calls them equal. If you are gonna trade into pets, do it because you want the pet, not as a store of value.
Items similar to Shadow Pumpkin
Closest pets items by value. Useful for stacking or substituting in a trade.
Shadow Pumpkin: quick answers
How much is Shadow Pumpkin worth in MM2?
The going rate is 3 as of September 2026. Among pets items it ranks 29 of 83.
What can I trade for Shadow Pumpkin?
These add up to about the same 3x Xeno Knife, 5x Eyes, 5x Pumpkin. Whatever you put together should come out near 3. Worth checking in the calculator so you know where you stand.
Is Shadow Pumpkin rare in MM2?
Rarity is rated 3 and demand 2, which puts it in the TIER 3 bracket of pets items. Not rare. You will not struggle to find one.
Is Shadow Pumpkin worth more than Chroma Fire Dog?
No. Chroma Fire Dog is worth 3 against 3 for Shadow Pumpkin. They sit next to each other on the list, so a straight swap is close to fair but tips slightly toward whoever gets Chroma Fire Dog.
Value last changed September 13, 2026. That is when the community trade feed we read was last rebuilt, not when you loaded this page. We pick up a change within ten minutes of it being published. The notes above are written and kept up by the MM2 Values Team, and how we source and check everything is in our editorial policy.
MM2 values are player-driven trade units. They are not Robux and carry no real-world money value.
Background on how Shadow Pumpkin was obtained and released: Shadow Pumpkin on the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki