Two listsBlue Pumpkin on MM2 Values vs Supreme Values
from supremevalues.com, the other community list. Why they differThe second list sits 5% higher. Most traders would call that the same price. They moved it up 10 (+4.8%) at their last refresh.
How much is Blue Pumpkin worth in MM2?
Blue Pumpkin is worth 210 today. Out of the 83 pets items that carry a price, that puts it at number 3. Across every priced item in the game it is number 188. Next to the pets median of 1, it comes in 210x that. Top of the tier is Zombie Dog at 725, about 3.5x what you have here.
2 out of 10 is quiet. Blue Pumpkin works better as part of a stack. Scarcer (5) than it is wanted (2). Expect the value to stick, and expect to wait for a buyer. This one holds its price. It has been flat a while, so there is no rush either way.
Trades that balance out: 3x Green Pumpkin (70 each), or 6x Candleflame (35 each), or 7x Zombified (30 each). On the list it sits between Bones Gun (200) and Bats Knife (250). Those are the two swaps people reach for when they do not have this one.
Fair offers for Blue Pumpkin
Stacks that come out close to even against Blue Pumpkin's 210.
| Offer | Each | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 3× Green Pumpkin | 70 | 210 |
| 6× Candleflame | 35 | 210 |
| 7× Zombified | 30 | 210 |
We round to whole items here, so these totals are close rather than exact. Work out the precise split in the trade calculator.
What pets items are, in short
Cosmetic, seasonal, and thinly traded.
Pets are the closest thing MM2 has to a collectible you buy for fun rather than profit.
Do not take a pet as the balancing item in a big trade. You may not be able to pass it on.
Items similar to Blue Pumpkin
Closest pets items by value. Useful for stacking or substituting in a trade.
Blue Pumpkin: quick answers
How much is Blue Pumpkin worth in MM2?
Current value is 210 (September 2026). That is 3rd of 83 pets items on this list.
What can I trade for Blue Pumpkin?
Try one of these 3x Green Pumpkin, 6x Candleflame, 7x Zombified. You are aiming for roughly 210 in total, however you get there. Drop both sides into the calculator before you accept.
Is Blue Pumpkin rare in MM2?
Rarity is rated 5 and demand 2, which puts it in the TIER 5 bracket of pets items. Moderately hard to find. Ask around and someone will have one.
Is Blue Pumpkin worth more than Bats Knife?
No. Bats Knife is worth 250 against 210 for Blue Pumpkin. They sit next to each other on the list, so a straight swap is close to fair but tips slightly toward whoever gets Bats Knife.
Value last changed September 13, 2026. That is when the community trade feed we read was last rebuilt, not when you loaded this page. We pick up a change within ten minutes of it being published. The notes above are written and kept up by the MM2 Values Team, and how we source and check everything is in our editorial policy.
MM2 values are player-driven trade units. They are not Robux and carry no real-world money value.
Background on how Blue Pumpkin was obtained and released: Blue Pumpkin on the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki